|

Cooking with Ratios

An image showing flour, butter milk and eggs and a weigh scale. this post is about Ratios in Baking.

Cooking with Ratios: A Simple Guide to Baking and Dressings

Ever wondered why some recipes use very similar amounts of flour, butter and sugar? Often, there’s a ratio behind them. Understanding a few basic cooking ratios can help you make sense of a recipe, adjust quantities and understand why your ingredients need to be in balance.

Trade-up your TM31, TM5 or TM6 to a TM7 (Australia only) – until 29th November

As a chef and pastry chef, I find ratios useful, but they’re only part of the picture. Ingredients and methods matter too. You don’t need to start developing your own recipes to benefit from knowing how the numbers work.

Let’s make it simple.

What is a cooking ratio?

A cooking ratio describes how much of one ingredient you use compared with another.

For example, a traditional shortbread ratio is three parts flour, two parts butter and one part sugar, written as 3:2:1.

Each “part” represents the same weight. If you choose 50 g per part, you’ll need:

  • 150 g plain flour
  • 100 g butter
  • 50 g sugar

Choose 100 g per part and those amounts become 300 g flour, 200 g butter and 100 g sugar. The batch is bigger, but the balance of ingredients stays the same.

The ingredient order matters. A ratio of 3:2:1 doesn’t tell you much unless you know which number belongs to which ingredient!

Should you use weight or volume for cooking ratios?

For baking, I recommend weighing your ingredients in grams. It’s how I write all my recipes because it gives more consistent results.

A ratio written by weight won’t give the same result if you swap the grams for cups. Flour, butter and sugar all have different weights for the same volume. Three cups of flour and two cups of butter won’t give you the same proportions as 300 g flour and 200 g butter.

Some ratios, such as a simple salad dressing, are commonly measured by volume. That’s fine, provided you follow the measurement basis given.

If you’re using a Thermomix, weighing directly into the bowl makes everything super easy. Otherwise, a set of kitchen scales will do the job.

Common cooking and baking ratios

These are useful starting points for understanding ingredient proportions. The baking examples aren’t complete recipes, so you’ll still need an appropriate method, cooking temperature and cooking time.

PreparationRatioExample
Basic bread dough5 parts flour : 3 parts water, by weight500 g flour + 300 g water, with salt and yeast added separately
Traditional shortbread3 parts flour : 2 parts butter : 1 part sugar, by weight150 g flour + 100 g butter + 50 g sugar
Traditional pound cakeEqual weights of butter, sugar, eggs and flour100 g of each ingredient, with eggs weighed without their shells
Simple vinaigrette3 parts oil : 1 part vinegar, by volume3 tablespoons oil + 1 tablespoon vinegar Or 60g oil and 20g vinegar Aussie Tablespoons

Bread: understanding the flour-to-water ratio

  • A basic bread ratio is five parts flour to three parts water. For 500 g flour, that gives you 300 g water.
  • You might also hear this described as 60% hydration. That simply means the water weighs 60% of the flour’s weight.
  • Salt is often calculated at around 2% of the flour weight, which would be 10 g for 500 g flour. Yeast needs a little more consideration because the amount depends on the type of yeast, the temperature and how long you want the dough to prove.
  • This ratio doesn’t suit every loaf. Wholemeal flour, added seeds and other ingredients can change how much water the dough needs. Think of it as a way to understand a basic dough, rather than a rule every bread recipe must follow.

Shortbread: the 3:2:1 ratio

Three parts flour, two parts butter and one part sugar is a traditional shortbread ratio.

It’s a useful one to remember, but it isn’t a formula for every biscuit. Adding eggs, changing the type of sugar or replacing some of the flour changes how the dough behaves. The method matters too. Ingredient proportions are only part of what gives a biscuit its texture.

Pound cake: equal weights (Butter Cakes)

Traditional pound cake uses equal weights of butter, sugar, eggs and flour. The name comes from using a pound of each, but the principle works with smaller quantities too. A pound of each makes a very large cake.

Weigh the eggs after cracking them into a bowl, without their shells. If you only need part of an egg, lightly beat it first, then weigh out the amount required. This is a pound cake ratio, rather than a rule for all butter cakes. Other cake recipes use different proportions, extra liquids or raising agents to achieve a particular result.

Vinaigrette: a starting point for salad dressing

A traditional vinaigrette starts with three parts oil to one part vinegar.

You can whisk them together or shake them in a jar, then season and taste. Try a little on a salad leaf rather than judging it only from a spoon. The vinegar you use makes a difference, and so does your preference. If the dressing is too sharp, add a little more oil. If it needs more acidity, add a little more vinegar. Mustard, herbs or a touch of sweetness can also help you make it your own.

There’s no prize for sticking to the ratio if you don’t enjoy the dressing. You do you.😉

Bakers hand with dough on a table, showing the Bakers Ratio with 3:2:1 on it.

How to calculate quantities from a ratio

Let’s say you have 100 g butter and want to work out the matching quantities for the 3:2:1 shortbread ratio.

  1. Butter represents two parts.
  2. Divide 100 g by two. That makes one part equal to 50 g.
  3. Multiply 50 g by three for the flour and by one for the sugar.

Your ingredient quantities are:

  • 150 g plain flour
  • 100 g butter
  • 50 g sugar

The same approach works whenever you know the ratio and the amount of one ingredient. When scaling a complete recipe, remember to adjust all the ingredients. A larger batch may also need a different tin, more mixing capacity and most likely an adjusted cooking time.

Why ratios don’t replace a tested recipe

Ratios help explain the balance of ingredients, but they can’t tell you everything about the finished result. Cold butter rubbed into flour behaves differently from butter creamed with sugar. Bread flour behaves differently from plain flour. Replacing sugar with honey introduces extra moisture as well as changing the sweetness.

That’s why I still test my recipes until I’m happy with them before I share. The numbers are useful, but I also want to know how the mixture handles, how it cooks and whether the result is something you’ll want to make again.

Start by noticing the proportions in recipes you already enjoy. You don’t have to change anything at first, just try to understand what might be happening.

Ratios are the backbone of cooking, particularly in baking where precision is key. Understanding the fundamental ratios of ingredients can transform your cooking from following recipes to creating them. It’s not just about measurements but about understanding the relationships between ingredients. Understanding a little bit about the science goes a long way in producing brilliant food.

Unlocking the Secret Language of Chefs. It’s all about the Ratios!

Need a refresher on ratios? Try this video by Michael Ruhlman.

I love this book, It has some great information in there if you’re interested.

The Power of Ratios for Cooking

Imagine making any bread without a recipe just by knowing the ratio of flour to water. Or whipping up the perfect vinaigrette with the knowledge of oil and vinegar (i.e., the ratio). This isn’t just efficient; it’s empowering. Many chef’s still don’t understand ratio’s but it’s great knowledge to have.

One last thought before we look at some common cooking ratios is that for Cooking and Baking, we generally refer to quantities by weight (e.g., grams or ounces). In some countries, recipes may use volume rather than weight (e.g., cups). Ratios will work in both cases, but you need to use only one measurement style within a recipe. I prefer to do everything by weight because it achieves more consistent results. If you have a recipe that’s written in volume and would like to “convert” to weight, download our free very handy 6 page conversion chart.

Key cooking Ratios

  1. Bread: The basic bread ratio is 5:3, flour to water. With this ratio in your arsenal, the world of bread is at your fingertips. You can explore different flours, hydrations, and additions like seeds and nuts from here. For example;
    • This means for every 5 parts flour, you use 3 parts water. For example, 300g flour and 180g water.
      • The other important quantities for bread are;
        • Salt: Around 2% of the flour weight (e.g. 6g salt for 300g flour) 
        • Yeast: Around 1% of the flour weight (e.g. 3g yeast for 300g flour) 
  2. Vinaigrette: A simple vinaigrette ratio is 3:1, oil to vinegar. This is a launching pad for endless variations—add herbs, garlic, or mustard to elevate your dressing, and you can whip up a salad you will win friends with.
  3. Cookies: The 1-2-3 cookie dough ratio (sugar: butter: flour) can be the base for an infinite variety of cookies, from simple sugar cookies to elaborate holiday treats. Of course, this ratio has many variations, but if you want cookies and don’t have a recipe, this works as a base. Other ingredients like eggs, baking powder, and flavourings can be added, but the core 3:2:1 ratio for the main dry, fat, and sweet components is the foundation.  For example, a cookie recipe could use:
    • 300g flour
    • 200g butter (or other fat)
    • 100g sugar
  4. Buttercake or Pound Cake: As you’ve probably worked out, the typical ratio for making a pound cake is a pound of each ingredient or 1:1:1:1. Of course, it doesn’t have to be a pound; it can be whatever amount you like. Here’s an example:
    • 250g unsalted butter
    • 250g sugar
    • 250g flour
    • 250g eggs

From Ratios to Innovations

Knowing these ratios simplifies the process and frees your creativity. By changing the types of ingredients while keeping the ratios generally the same, you can create something entirely new and exciting every time you cook or bake. That’s what I try to do. 😁

10 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *