| |

British Custard Cream Biscuits

Close up of British Custard Cream Biscuits on a black plate.

If you’ve ever had a Custard Cream biscuit, you’ll know why they’re such a beloved British classic. Whether you grew up enjoying these with a cup of tea, or you’ve only recently discovered them, this recipe will transport you straight to the UK. And if you have any British friends, you’ll be sure to give them a nostalgic treat they’ll love!

Trade-up your TM31, TM5 or TM6 to a TM7 (Australia only) – until 29th November

Custard Creams are quite similar to our Yo-Yo biscuits, featuring that familiar melt-in-your-mouth texture. However, they have a slightly stronger custard flavour that distinguishes them. These biscuits are soft and buttery, yet if you manage to get the baking time just right, they can also have a slight crispness when you bite into them. Plus, they’re filled with a creamy vanilla centre. Let me share a trick to help you achieve the perfect result!

A cooling rack with custard cream biscuits.

You must bake Custard Cream biscuits with Care

These biscuits are delicate, so you’ll want to bake them until they’re firm enough to handle when you add the filling. If you under-bake them, they’ll be soft and tender, but you might end up with too many casualties when you try to sandwich them together. Aim for a light golden colour to achieve just the right firmness so they’re strong enough to hold the filling without crumbling and falling apart.

Cream Filling – Thin or Thick, you decide!

When it comes to the filling, I kept mine on the thinner side for a subtle balance between biscuit and cream. But if you’re a fan of that creamy goodness, feel free to double the filling ingredients for a richer, more indulgent experience.

Custard creams on a cooling rack with cream filling on top.

A British Classic with a Twist

While these Custard Creams have their roots in Britain, they’re so similar to Yo-Yo biscuits in texture and flavour that they’ll feel familiar to anyone who loves a good biscuit. But that extra custardy punch makes them just a little bit special. Give them a try and share them with your friends, especially those with a soft spot for British treats. They’ll love the trip down memory lane!


Looking down on a black plate filled with finished custard cream biscuits.
Finished British Custard Cream Biscuits

Tips for Success:

  • Be gentle: These biscuits are fragile, so don’t overwork the dough, and make sure they’re cooled before adding the filling.
  • Filling options: Thin or thick, it’s up to you! Adjust the cream filling recipe to suit your taste. A single batch will give you a very thin layer, double if you want more.
  • Perfect bake time: Aim for just the right balance – baked enough to hold together but still soft and delicate.

Enjoy making these Custard Creams, and don’t forget to have a cup of tea on hand for when they’re ready! 😊

Looking down on top of a black plate filled with custard cream biscuits

British Custard Cream Biscuits

4.75 from 4 votes

5 stars tells us you love the recipe

becs-table.com.au
These British Custard Cream Biscuits are a classic treat, similar in texture to YoYo biscuits but with an extra custard flavour. Delicate and buttery, they’re sandwiched with a smooth vanilla cream filling. Follow this recipe for tips on getting the perfect bake.
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 11 minutes
Total Time 36 minutes
Difficulty Easy
Course Afternoon Tea, Biscuits, Cookies Biscuits
Cuisine British
Servings 18
Method Thermomix

Equipment

  • 1 Thermomix

Ingredients
  

  • 170 g plain flour
  • 65 g custard powder I used Bird’s Custard Powder, available at some Woolworths
  • 60 g soft icing sugar
  • ¼ tsp baking soda
  • Pinch of salt I used pink flaked
  • 170 g butter good quality, no added water, cold, cut into small cubes

Filling

  • 30 g butter room temperature
  • 60 g icing sugar
  • 5 g vanilla extract

Instructions
 

Method (Thermomix)

    Mix dry ingredients:

    • Weigh the flour, custard powder, icing sugar, baking soda, and salt into your Thermomix bowl.
    • MC in / Mix for 5 seconds / Speed 6.

    Add butter:

    • Weigh the cold butter cubes into the bowl and mix for 25–30 seconds / Speed 5. The mixture should look like large crumbs. Don’t over-mix, or it’ll be too sticky to remove from the bowl!

    Shape the dough:

    • Tip the dough onto a baking sheet and bring it together by hand. Cover with another sheet of baking paper. (See tips).

    Roll out the dough:

    • Roll to your desired thickness using a rolling pin. Remember, you’ll be sandwiching two biscuits together with cream, so don’t make them too thick.

    Cut the biscuits:

    • I used an Acrylic Fondant Imprint Mat for a patterned finish, and a ruler with a knife to cut them to the desired shape. Chill the biscuits while preheating your oven.

    Preheat the oven:

    • Preheat your oven (or benchtop oven) to 160°C fan.

    Bake:

    • Bake the biscuits for 11 minutes or until they have a slight amount of colour. (See tips).

    For the Filling:

    • Blend ingredients: See tips on whether you want a thin or thick layer of filling. Weigh all the filling ingredients into your Thermomix bowl. MC in / Blend at Speed 5 until smooth. You may need to scrape down the sides, but once the butter softens, it’ll form a smooth paste.

    Notes

    If you’re unfamiliar with filling soft, delicate, biscuits, then consider making the biscuits a bit thicker and baking them for a minute or two longer. The softer they are, the more fragile they’ll be, and you risk them crumbling while spreading the filling.
    Don’t bake these on a silicone mat. Use baking paper or a thin baking sheet to ensure even cooking on both the top and bottom.
    When rolling out the dough, cover it with a sheet of baking paper to avoid sticking.
    To prepare the filling, I rolled it out between two sheets of baking paper and placed it in the freezer for 15 minutes. Afterwards, I quickly removed it, cut it into the desired shapes, and returned it to the freezer to firm up again. This way, the filling was frozen in discs, making it easy to transfer onto the biscuits once they had cooled.

    Want to know more?

    Perhaps a look at our other Cookies and Biscuits?

    22 Comments

      1. Hey Judy, I’m happy for you to add any of my public blog recipes to Cookidoo. I only share them from Cookidoo once someone other than me has tested them. All I ask is that you add “Bec’s Table” to the beginning of the recipe name. In this case: “Bec’s Table: British Custard Cream Biscuits”.

        1. Thanks Bec. I was looking for the “send to Cookidoo” link you sometimes have in your recipes. All good. I’ll try them first then see if I’m clever enough to add to my favourites – I have a feeling they will be!

    1. Can these biscuits be frozen once cooked, with or without filling please. Hoping to do baking for events a few weeks out 🥰. Just cooking a batch now and trying 2mm with 2/3 mix fingers crossed. If not, will try 3mm 🤷🏽‍♀️.

      1. Hi Kathy, yes you can freeze them. You can even fill them and freeze. Pop them in a sealed container in the freezer. In our cafe we would remove biscuits like these from the freezer the night before and pop them in the fridge till morning. First thing we’d fill our biscuit barrels.

        1. 4 stars
          Thank you so much for your quick reply. The freezer tips are terrific as I may be prone to eating too many too if they are not hidden. 😜. I’ll make a second batch of the coffee scrolls biscuits too to freeze – perfect!

          Have just made the biscuits 2mm which taste buttery and lovely. Some were thinner and even post freezer hollowed-out a little, but the flavour is divine and I popped a little extra icing in the middle. Again thank you – really appreciate your thermie recipes and helpfulness!

        2. Thank you so much for your quick reply. The freezer tips are terrific as I may be prone to eating too many too if they are not hidden. 😜. I’ll make a second batch of the coffee scrolls biscuits too to freeze – perfect!

          Have just made the biscuits 2mm which taste buttery and lovely. Some were thinner and even post freezer hollowed-out a little, but the flavour is still divine!

          Again thank you – really appreciate your thermie recipes and helpfulness! 🌻

          1. I’m not sure if you have an air fryer, but I use mine a lot these days and find it so handy. I like to shape my biscuits, place them on trays, and freeze them raw. You can put them really close together at this stage. Once they’re frozen, I slide them into ziplock bags or containers. Then, when I want some, I just bake as many as I need. I have a bench-top oven-style air fryer, and it fits one tray at a time, which is usually just right for my husband and me.

    4.75 from 4 votes

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating